Apporintments: (607) 988-9898 | After Hours Emergency Commercial Tire Repairs: (607) 437-5728

M – Sat: 8am to 5pm

339 Co. Hwy 48
Otego, NY 13825
Exit 12 off I88

Call or Fax:
(607) 988-9898

Emergency Commercial Tire Repairs:
(607) 437-5728

24 / 7 Emergency Service

Semi Tire Repair & Replacement


Farm Tire Repairs & Replacement

Welcome To

Otego Tire & Auto

We would like to introduce Gene Brown as the new Owner / Operator here at Otego Tire & Auto. Gene has been a part of the OTA team for 12 years, and was Bart’s business partner for the last 3 years.

Gene, and the rest of the team here at OTA, would like to congratulate Bart Sheldon (the founder and owner of OTA for the last 12 years) on his retirement.

Anyone who has ever met Bart, knows the dedication that he had to OTA, its team, and it’s customers – whether it be opening the shop at 6am and waiting for the day to start or staying late to get a customer back on the road.

We have been joking about retirement for years, because Bart is a workaholic (and we thank you for that). Bart and Mary are 2 of the most wonderful and deserving people we have ever met, and none of us could be happier to see you finally enjoying the life you have worked so hard to get to.

Once again, we congratulate Bart and Mary – happy retirement!

The Otego Tire & Auto Promise

We Know That Success Comes From Servicing Our Customers Well, At Every Opportunity, For Years To Come. We know how frustrating it can be to receive an initial estimate that’s way off base, or to wonder whether you’re going to be hit with hidden costs when it’s time to settle up. That’s why you’ll receive out-the-door price quotes before service begins. No wait. No worries.

Take the time to understand your individual situation and precisely what your vehicle requires

Service or repair your vehicle to manufacturer’s specifications

Inform you of other maintenance or safety repair needs

Treat you like a friend as well as our customer

Warranty our work

Online & In-Shop

Tire Buying

Buy Tires Online

What We Do

Our Services & Specials

  • Computerized Diagnostic
  • Computerized Alignment
  • Computerized Tire Balancing
  • Lube, oil & filter
  • Brake services
  • NYS Vehicle Inspections & Safety Checks
  • Radiator & coolant system services
  • Engine & transmission services
  • Emission control
  • Tune Up
  • Fuel Injection
  • Tires Sales
  • Tire Repair
  • Plus Much More!

Businesses, Ask About Our

Fleet Maintenance Program

Undercoat For Any Car

Powerful corrosion protection for all metals and superior lubrication for all moving parts

Proud Authorized Dealer

Custom Wheels from AutoAdditctions. Check out the Online Visualizer and order from OTA for the best price!

Car Repair Financing

Make car care easier on the wallet with simple car care financing with Synchrony. Click for details.

We Love Your Support

What Our Customers Are Saying

    review rating 5  Went in after a recommendation from customers at Jake's deli. John was able to offer alternatives to what we felt was a costly and complicated solution to our friends heater core issue. I highly recommend places such as Otego Tire and Auto since the staff could have easily not gone the extra mile to present other option. To me that is a strong sign of integrity. :) #ChrisCortez603 #RAoK603

    thumb ChrisCortez603 RAoK603

    review rating 5  Wonderful, normally my son the mechanic, infact he is the only one I previously let work on my car but due to his busy schedule I had to find a garage for pressing matters. A friend suggested this place and I can’t say enough good about them. They told me the same thing my son did and were very knowledgeable. I’m very pleased.

    thumb Penny Barnes

    review rating 5  Good business. Bring my car in frequently

    thumb Cooper Wilms

Exit 12 off I-88
339 Co. Hwy 48
Otego, NY 13825

P: (607) 988-9898
F: (607) 988-9898